logoalt Hacker News

ibudiallotoday at 1:32 AM1 replyview on HN

The missing underscore didn't send an innocent man to prison. In this story, an incompetent lawyer, an incompetent judge, and an unjust system walked into a bar...

When the article says "he was found guilty" what does that even mean? "found" implies there was evidence. Throughout the article, it clearly says there was no evidence from all searches. What did they find? Not a pixelated picture, not an ip address, not even an AI auto classifying him as prime suspect.

What did the detective on the case have to say?

> Detective: "Yep, that's the user name"

> Partner: "What about the email, does it match?"

> Detective: "Email? what's that? Is that like a fax machine?"


Replies

kmosertoday at 2:08 AM

> When the article says "he was found guilty" what does that even mean? "found" implies there was evidence.

IANAL but to be "found guilty" means you are determined to be, in the eyes of the law, guilty. Actual guilt is irrelevant. As for evidence, there's the "matching" username (which, we all now know, didn't really match).