logoalt Hacker News

arnejenssenlast Tuesday at 6:11 PM6 repliesview on HN

For me the value of Garmin (Forerunner) is their proprietary algorithm for calculating Stress Level from HRV. It is the basis for the Body Battery measure. I find it useful to see how food and activity affects my stress levels.

I guess it would be possible to reverse engineer a similar stress level calculation. Perhaps AI-powered?


Replies

scheme271last Tuesday at 6:37 PM

I'm not sure the body battery/stress measures are that great. Garmin is infamous for having an awful sleep algo and it still has a lot of trouble detecting naps. It doesn't bode well for being able to get stress data. I think it's good for generally determining high stress vs low stress and when you've overdone exercise recently but probably not much more.

show 1 reply
TekMollast Tuesday at 6:25 PM

If the algorithm is proprietary, how do you know it is calculating something meaningful?

elricyesterday at 12:00 PM

My Garmin Epix's Body Battery levels might as well be randomly generated. They don't correlate at all to how I feel. YMMV.

ck2last Tuesday at 7:09 PM

HRV from optical is garbage-in garbage-out

and post-2020 Garmin has totally lost their way with development/algorithms

mtmailyesterday at 11:19 AM

Is that calculated locally or send to the cloud? I got fed up how many Garmin features required an account.

kilroy123last Tuesday at 6:38 PM

Yes, and the sleep tracking that adds or subtracts. While not super accurate, it's good enough for me.