logoalt Hacker News

georgemcbayyesterday at 9:27 PM1 replyview on HN

Even for older models I was (and am) of the opinion that a lot of the context-overstuffing cruft people have been wrapping around their LLM usage is more of an RNG-impacting (but not always for the better) lucky charm rather than it being universally helpful.

And a lot of people latched on to it as a form of self-soothing.

"I may not write much code anymore, but I can still be an expert prompt engineer!"


Replies

troupoyesterday at 9:59 PM

> is more of an RNG-impacting (but not always for the better) lucky charm rather than it being universally helpful.

I wrote this last year, it's still true:

--- start quote ---

https://dmitriid.com/prompting-llms-is-not-engineering

In reality these are just shamanic rituals with outcomes based on faith, fear, or excitement. Engineering it is not.

--- end quote ---

There are some prompts useful for the user like brainstorming [1] but on the whole it's nothing but lucky charms

[1] brainstorming from superpowers: https://github.com/obra/superpowers