logoalt Hacker News

WJWyesterday at 1:01 PM3 repliesview on HN

Security minded programmers understand that. "People" as a whole have not even heard about mixing instructions and data, and certainly not the reasons why it is not a good idea.

And AI chatbots are very much targeted at the second group, not the first.


Replies

TeMPOraLyesterday at 1:19 PM

> "People" as a whole have not even heard about mixing instructions and data, and certainly not the reasons why it is not a good idea.

Because it's not a concept in the real world. Physical reality has no such separation, and neither do human minds.

Tell people you're discussing a board game or some sport, then they'll understand - other than bureaucracy (scary!) and school (traumatic!), that's the one kind of artificial system with rules affording for code/data separation that general population has most experience dealing with.

show 1 reply
NegativeLatencyyesterday at 1:48 PM

Even engineers like doing it sometimes. The old telephone system was so hackable because of in band signaling.

show 3 replies
iamacyborgyesterday at 1:13 PM

> And AI chatbots are very much targeted at the second group, not the first.

I suppose this is why the AI labs are famously not releasing developer-oriented tools.

show 2 replies