logoalt Hacker News

nvme0n1p1yesterday at 6:00 PM4 repliesview on HN

> I’m genuinely confused at how it caught on

Probably because they said AI rewrote it in 11 days, yet haven't cut a release almost 2 months later. If their AI finished it, where's the release?

They ported enough of it to run a single app (Claude Code). Good job. But if I ported Linux to Rust and it was only capable of running a single app, should I be able say it was a complete port? We'd all agree that was misleading. It's the same with Bun.

The marketing lies simply backfired.


Replies

simonwyesterday at 6:29 PM

> If their AI finished it, where's the release?

Producing a stable release for their community of code that had been written by AI in 11 days and had not yet been extensively tested in the real world would be grossly irresponsible.

Instead, they made the AI rewrite available as a canary release and shipped it for a month as part of Claude Code to millions of their own users.

show 2 replies
johnfnyesterday at 6:56 PM

> If their AI finished it, where's the release?

`bun upgrade --canary`. You can use it today.

Keeping a large release, like a total rewrite, on canary for a while to iron out bugs is a very reasonable software engineering practice.

show 1 reply
fhnyesterday at 7:06 PM

Would you release it when it's not complete?

show 1 reply
daishi55yesterday at 10:35 PM

What did they lie about in your opinion? CC is using the rust version right now.

> a single app

I mean this is a very silly way to describe one of the most used developer tools in the world, don’t you think?