logoalt Hacker News

fidotrontoday at 1:32 PM2 repliesview on HN

Surely having the idea and curating the result actually is work?

And pricing is determined by what someone else will pay for something, so if people want to read it and the author is charging for it . . . that's up to them if they want to make a trade about it.

The odd thing is this attempt at gatekeeping what other people value.


Replies

zbentleytoday at 4:37 PM

> pricing is determined by what someone else will pay for something

That’s so reductive that even Keynes would probably take issue.

Discoverability is the axis of competition in this context, not price. The market has not effectively found out how to identify quality in order to price it, so externalities rule instead: pre-existing authors with recognizable names, whatever genre publishers like at a given moment (famously disconnected from what people actually want to buy), how many energy drinks a crabby editor has had by the time they get to your manuscript, and so on.

Search engine and recommendation systems were supposed to ameliorate those externalities. They didn’t.

harimau777today at 2:20 PM

Price is determined by what someone is willing to pay but value isn't. If the value from art comes from expression, then LLMs directly attack the core value of art.

show 2 replies