I don't know why the framing. This is easy: review the cases. If it has his hand it's tainted one way or the other. That's it.
How is it tainted by that alone? It’s almost certain that at least some of the patients he amputated actually needed amputation.
Could ask this about most news stories these days. They are so bold as to not even hide the opinionated framing anymore.
How is it tainted by that alone? It’s almost certain that at least some of the patients he amputated actually needed amputation.