logoalt Hacker News

damstayesterday at 11:17 PM5 repliesview on HN

I don't think audio, image or video generation should exist. I haven't seen enough positive applications to justify the amount of harm these tools are being used to cause.


Replies

chrysopracetoday at 2:27 AM

While I generally think it's balanced against a lot of negative applications (misinformation, deepfakes, etc.), there are some good applications. I think regulation just hasn't sufficiently caught up with the harm they can cause.

To give a good use case (audio generation specifically), the 2002 game Morrowind has had a resurgence lately and it's a really great game, but it lacks fully voiced lines for dialogue. A community project called Voices of Vvardenfell uses ElevenAI to generate voice lines from the voiced lines that do exist in the game. They don't take away jobs from artists because it was a monumental (unpaid) undertaking from community volunteers to do this before (there was such a big project but it was abandoned last I saw).

So as with any emerging technologies, I think it just needs to be properly regulated.

argentinianyesterday at 11:58 PM

Now they cause harm because there's people that may believe a fake video is real. But people is developing skepticism about what they see in videos and learning to think that they may be generated, before taking them as true.

What kind of harms do you have in mind?

show 1 reply
vitalyan8184today at 12:07 AM

[dead]

p-e-wtoday at 12:12 AM

For everything that exists, there are people who think it shouldn’t exist. Fortunately, society doesn’t ban everything that disagrees with some people, and even more fortunately, we now live in a multipolar world where what is available doesn’t depend on the whims of a single pseudo-moralistic government.

E-Reveranceyesterday at 11:44 PM

> I haven't seen enough positive applications

If in the future they can create a reward model to aid with creating super human levels of appeal tailored to me, I would considered it one of the best technologies ever made. I'm not sentimental about the source, pretty videos and pictures make me happy