alt Hacker NewsI don't think it's a bad way to benchmark new models, I just find it concerning that the author implies that "pelican on a bicycle" has been exhausted. At the risk of making overly broad, unfalsifiable claims I think multi-year exposure to AI content has dramatically raised our expectations for speed and volume but lowered them for quality. We see a very janky pelican and declare the problem solved.
Replies
I think it's touching the limit of what one can reasonably expect any intelligent thing to produce with the only direction being "produce an svg of a pelican riding a bicycle".
When you aren't sure if an LLM can write an svg well, or that it will be able to form a pelican shape, or animate a bicycle, it's a good test. After that, it's all judgement: how detailed should the pelican be? pelicans are the wrong shape for a bicycle by default, so how much can I change its physiology to match using a bicycle before it isn't a pelican? Do I care about how well the client is able to render complex geometry?
It's not that there isn't room to do better, or that it doesn't tell you anything at all, but rather we've reached a point where what it tells us isn't very clear anymore.
Also, one of the advantages of the pelican test is that you can evaluate it all at once. There’s no reason the two-dimensional depiction can’t be made more challenging. Yes, at some point the pelicans might approach the subjectivity of a fine art painting, but we haven’t even seen a depiction that’s competent by the standards of a high school art class. That’s not to say the elementary school–level SVGs aren’t amazing - rather, I agree with your point.
100%. Why waste the tokens to render Lord of the Rings when the pelican test still clearly benchmarks so well.
I don't think he's claiming it's been exhausted. It's just that things have progressed to a point where people are arguing over the finer points of which pelican looks better -- which is often a matter of taste, and an indication that we've hit the knee in benchmark where models are no longer failing in obviously awful ways.