logoalt Hacker News

Californians' data deletion requests, DROP, become enforceable Aug. 1

116 pointsby MilnerRouteyesterday at 10:16 PM50 commentsview on HN

Comments

ryandraketoday at 3:35 AM

As good intentioned as it is, I don't like the wording used around this law. "Request" and "Ask" and "please delete my information." Notice that regular users have to "ask nicely" but when it's something like the DMCA, which benefits corporations, they use "takedown notices" and "demand letters."

I don't want to ask data brokers, pretty please with sugar on top. I want to be able to demand they do it, and require them to immediately do it and provide proof that they did, under penalty of perjury.

petilonyesterday at 11:24 PM

I hope other states adopt this. One of the biggest mistakes I have made is giving my real phone number to Dun & Bradstreet. Now the spam calls and messages (from people they sold my info to) won't stop. I don't want to change my phone number.

show 5 replies
bdcravenstoday at 12:09 AM

I wonder if there will be any funny data issues that happen because companies keep track of such requests in a table named "drop"

show 1 reply
igor47yesterday at 11:02 PM

I've been thinking of making a service which automatically sends deletion requests for all my service companies every month. Like, I currently keep a bunch of spyware features in my car turned of, but I have to keep location turned on to use the built in navigation which keeps track of range for me. Would be nice to have a ceiling on that data's retention.

Long term, if compliance with data deletion requests becomes a pain, maybe companies will finally give us an opt out of surveillance capitalism? Or maybe they'll just lock me out of my own car (I guess it's their car since I don't have root on it, lol)

show 1 reply
MrZanderyesterday at 11:21 PM

Out of curiosity, does anyone know how this is enforceable for a company not based in California? Can CA fine a data broker that is based in another state but that is selling CA residents' information?

show 3 replies
ChrisArchitecttoday at 2:54 AM

Some previous Delete / Drop Act discussion:

The Delete Act

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46449694

California residents can now request all data brokers delete personal info

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46495220

hackernud3syesterday at 11:13 PM

What about unregistered data-brokers? I would he happy to sign up to webhooks for when someone wants to delete data.

Problem is though, you'd be revealing more data about them than I probably have by sending it.

tjwebbnorfolktoday at 1:22 AM

> Companies that fail to comply can face fines of $200 per day for each affected Californian.

Does this cover things like credit reports/scores? If someone submits a request to this DROP thing, is it possible data gets deleted that they don't intend?

show 2 replies
echelonyesterday at 11:16 PM

Does this mean people can delete comments from HN?

show 2 replies
unstatusthequoyesterday at 11:19 PM

The Advertising ID field/ Nice of them to think of this, but it doesn't seem that I could actually get this from any of my Samsung TVs, Apple devices, apps?, etc? So while that field is nice and all, without transparency on getting the ad ID, those fields kind of do nothing.

show 1 reply
faucetltoday at 2:43 AM

[flagged]

garpoontoday at 2:19 AM

[dead]

amazingamazingyesterday at 11:20 PM

Why is there a time limit on deletion on this site?

show 2 replies