logoalt Hacker News

jpnctoday at 6:33 AM10 repliesview on HN

If you create a machine for laziness you're going to get lazy people. It's only going to get worse I'm afraid.

Do you guys think we're going to see a de-evolution of human beings due to technology?


Replies

tarkin2today at 10:29 AM

Arguably we already have, if you concentrate on intelligence rates since 1975: the reverse Flynn affect. Those who grew up about that time no longer had to generate their own entertainment through storytelling, make their own music, calculate things mentally: everyday they had music, entertainment pumped into their homes, a way to avoid athematic, etc. And now we're evening thinking a lot less in our jobs, not even practicing the skills we learnt. Intelligence is only going to decrease.

show 2 replies
cm2187today at 9:01 AM

It’s tempting to use what engineers were 70 years ago vs now as an analogy. From a technical point of view, I was told we would be struggling to solve the maths and physics exercises our grand fathers took as students in college, and they had to deal with additional disciplines that disappeared like industrial design (ie drawing blueprints by hand) or manual calculus. So it is tempting to think that the level of engineers has gone down.

But a modern engineer has computers, math software, can code, has all the knowledge of the internet at their fingertips. With all that assistance I believe modern engineers are way more productive and capable.

show 1 reply
Yiintoday at 6:43 AM

I didn't expect wall-e to become so close to current reality

show 1 reply
usef-today at 8:01 AM

Similar to physical exercise and machines replacing it, I think we're going to see extremes on both ends.

Cthulhu_today at 9:16 AM

Not sure about de-evolution (devolution is the word I think), just a change in how people and brains work - but you could already see this happening the past few decades. I can't read a technical book or documentation end to end ever since google results came up with specific answers within seconds.

show 1 reply
jayd16today at 7:28 AM

All machines are for laziness.

show 3 replies
64e23275635etoday at 6:47 AM

it's already happening. IQ is already stagnating or even going down

show 3 replies
f6vtoday at 7:55 AM

Human intelligence evolved without technology, so, no.

show 1 reply
ryu2k2today at 6:46 AM

We're already seeing it.

Applejinxtoday at 9:48 AM

Alcohol has existed for zillions of years, but not literally every person is a useless drunkard.

You could consider it a class of predator on people who have vulnerabilities that can give way to dependence on the LLM and an inability to function. It could be seen in that light. The underlying problem is being described in that light.