logoalt Hacker News

RandomLensmantoday at 5:40 PM4 repliesview on HN

Germany cut off Russian gas? Gazprom suspended supply indefinitely via NS1 before it was destroyed.


Replies

goobatroobatoday at 7:23 PM

Markets are now committed than a single pipeline. Germany was importing most gas through other channels - pipelines through Eastern and Southern Europe and shipping - as well as of course plenty of oil. While the NortStream cut had a significant short term impact it took much more effort to wean the country off all the other routes.

show 1 reply
1239176today at 8:22 PM

That is a half truth. A turbine was broken, repaired in Canada, which required a lot of bureaucracy. Then the turbine was shipped to Germany. Then the Russians started their own bureaucracy and came up with excuses why the turbine could not be installed.

During that time Nord Stream was blown up.

The point is moot, since Putin has offered multiple times to open the remaining intact pipe:

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/putin-urges-germany-...

And the broken pipes can be repaired, as was determined in the LLoyds lawsuit recently.

I'm not saying that reopening would be reliable, but it would be one diversification away from US and Qatar dependencies. The US just cut the EU off from Qatar gas.

freehorsetoday at 5:43 PM

When we are talking about countries, what matters is the political decisions, not the technical details imo.

show 1 reply
pydrytoday at 6:06 PM

Canada sanctioned the repaired gas turbines needed to operate NS1. They flip flopped on their decision some time later though.

This was spun as a Russian decision, but western countries were clearly trying to force Germany's hand.

show 3 replies