logoalt Hacker News

saghmyesterday at 8:39 PM1 replyview on HN

If a malicious site gets your password, I'm not sure why it matters whether it happened in the frontend or not.


Replies

LocalHyesterday at 10:30 PM

Bad actors have been social engineering passwords for years even before a single line of JS was written. Restricting the backend is a way of heavily reducing the attack surface. The expansion of hardware access to browsers is the largest scam enabler of the 21st century. The only reason it's happening in the long term is because companies like Google (DoubleClick) wish to use hardware attestation to tie people to hardware for advertisement purposes, and that requires complete vertical attestation.

We're losing general-purpose computing like frogs in a slow cooker, and millions of people don't even notice. Fuck TPM, fuck hardware attestation, no internet company should get a single bit from me that I don't authorize. Any site that requires hardware attestation will be a hard "no" for me to ever visit again.

I maintain this all started when commerce was introduced to the internet. Things were better before money was transferred digitally. Allowing that was a major fuckup.