logoalt Hacker News

asveikautoday at 2:04 AM2 repliesview on HN

Doesn't zwave use a different frequency, and zigbee and thread are both 2.4ghz? Perhaps that makes it a more fair comparison?


Replies

SEJefftoday at 3:11 AM

Yes, zwave is in the much less congested 900mhz range. It is a fair bit more reliable as it doesn’t compete with:

- WiFi

- Bluetooth

- microwave ovens

Additionally, it’s a bit more strict with certification so you can easily use multiple vendors for zwave whereas with zigbee it’s often a terrible experience since vendors implement things differently in ways that are not as interoperable. In fact, for a device to be certified by the zwave alliance, it must pass strict conformance testing to ensure backwards compatibility and interoperability.

unsnap_bicepstoday at 3:02 AM

some zigbee controllers even support being converted to thread via a firmware update