logoalt Hacker News

rwmjtoday at 12:57 PM2 repliesview on HN

Hard disks used to come with a paper label listing their bad sectors. (They still come with a list, it's just now it is hidden in the firmware like you describe.)


Replies

alnwlsntoday at 1:19 PM

I do some retro-computing every now and then and of these old drives that still work (about a 50% chance), when I format them assuming all sectors are good, they will inevitably report the same bad sectors as is on the label.

I don't really know why "bad sectors are still bad after 40 years" is so surprising to me, but there you go.

show 1 reply
lxgrtoday at 12:58 PM

And the firmware remaps them, as far as I know. That's very different from a firmware exposing a bad sector list to the host, which is the case for some flash systems, I believe.

show 1 reply