logoalt Hacker News

aucisson_masquetoday at 9:22 PM3 repliesview on HN

Aosp without Google play services is dead. You need it more and more to run apps.


Replies

getpokedagaintoday at 9:40 PM

This is only true of ye olde apps from shitty banks and the like.

grueztoday at 10:42 PM

>You need it more and more to run apps.

Realistically nobody is developing apps for linux phones, so the options are android or no apps at all.

hagbard_ctoday at 9:42 PM

Strange, I've been using it for about 15 years on many different devices and it works just fine. Maybe that is related to the fact that I tend to shun closed-source applications whenever possible? The few closed-source apps I do use - Swedish BankID, Deutsche Bahn 'Navigator', Dutch DigiD - also work as intended even though some of them - mostly the Swedish BankID - claim they 'need Google Services to work'. Click away the popup and it works just fine without it so that is clearly not true. On some devices I installed microG to see whether it does what they claim but while this seems to be the case I don't think it is needed for those keeping their devices mostly free from proprietary applications. This is not a hardship, far from it. Nearly all the types of applications I want to use are available as free software which also tends to make them ad-free, spyware-free and generally less of a nuisance than proprietary alternatives.