logoalt Hacker News

unsupp0rtedyesterday at 9:55 PM4 repliesview on HN

> the telegraph, the telephone, the television

None of those let a random person Hawk Tuah their way to reaching millions. Seriously: x disintermediates and offers distribution in a way no other communication tech does.

Granted you can always post a blog or whatever, but X's ambition to be the "town square" is a valid one and it does achieve it in notable ways, even if there's still 100 years worth of improvement needed.


Replies

dgellowyesterday at 10:14 PM

The town square concept has never made sense. The idea that you have a place where everybody goes and scream at each others insults non stop is completely insane in the real world

show 1 reply
mindslightyesterday at 10:10 PM

> None of those let a random person Hawk Tuah their way to reaching millions

Onlyfans was included under "almost every single aspect of the internet".

bigyabaiyesterday at 10:00 PM

> None of those let a random person Hawk Tuah their way to reaching millions.

I take it you didn't watch much daytime television? Or YouTube?

X is not designed or moderated in a reputable, accountable or unbiased fashion - and neither was Twitter. X's ambition to be a "town square" is a solipsistic delusion that even Dorsey managed to avoid (despite all the mistakes he did make).

100 years worth of improvement isn't enough, X's centralized design is inherently abusive and many communities have already moved on. As Terry Davis would have put it, X glows.

show 1 reply
blokeyyesterday at 10:02 PM

I guess.

If the town itself is an aids-ridden, nazi infested bunch of child-porn-creating yobs.

They can keep that town and its square. I'd nuke it from orbit, only way to be sure.