logoalt Hacker News

pfdietztoday at 7:28 PM1 replyview on HN

Sorry, when you make an assertion, you don't get to demand I justify questioning it. You need to explain why I should believe you.

Your reversal of burden of proof is a red flag that you don't have a good argument.

IMO, it is quite plausible that OoL is extremely unlikely and that our solar system is the only place where life occurs in the visible universe. Not proved, of course, but the possibility is by no means unreasonable.


Replies

ck2today at 9:10 PM

wasn't demanding, just wanted to hear what your own logic was instead

but it's pointless to go any further I guess as it's getting outside science

the weak anthropic principle can't be falsified so it cannot be argued

I don't think we'll ever hear from "ET" but I do think it's perfectly plausible to find single-celled or simple bacteria elsewhere someday (ie. Europa, comet or asteroid)