logoalt Hacker News

Rohansiyesterday at 11:41 PM1 replyview on HN

Those are very different scenarios because your "protection" is the threat of consequences. You can freely buy and use knives, you can drive your own car, but you can only use your phone to do what Apple approves of? Sure, banning knives, replacing cars with public transport, and locking down all computers should be safer in theory... but murderers will still murder and scammers will still scam.

Social engineering is the weakest link even if your grandma is doing all her banking on Windows XP.


Replies

ceejayozyesterday at 11:48 PM

> You can freely buy and use knives…

No, not necessarily. Quite a few countries have restrictions on knives, including some parts of the US - a switchblade will get you in trouble in NYC.

> you can drive your own car

Only in approved ways!

Hell, you'll get in trouble if your gasoline is the wrong color.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_dye#Fuel_dye_in_North_Ame...

"Detection of red-dyed fuel in the fuel system of an on-road vehicle will incur substantial penalties."

> murderers will still murder and scammers will still scam

Do we not take steps to try and reduce murder?

show 1 reply