logoalt Hacker News

comboytoday at 4:10 PM3 repliesview on HN

Not sure it works, isn't it already like that if you have the cursed javascript-only pages? It's basically proof of work to access their content (and if you are scrapping en masse you likely also need some LLM getting involved)


Replies

littlecranky67today at 4:43 PM

Problem is I'd rather have the 0.05cents go to however runs the website (the bugtracker in this case) than go to the electricity company.

port11today at 4:41 PM

I suppose the cost of hardware, network usage, and electricity is still under 0.05? I mean, we know the unit economics for LLMs don't make a ton of sense, except if enterprise customers really are what keeps the lights on.

tarpitttoday at 4:43 PM

With micropayments, the server owner makes 1 million requests times 0.05 cents = ~$500

The status quo with those js PoW pages doesn't really benefit the server owner at all, it's wasted energy.

I mean proof of work is always wasted energy, but I figure it's better to kill two birds with one stone.

CoinHive was one example of this. (I think this is a correct link? https://github.com/cazala/coin-hive). Although I think ideally you would want to have some sort of browser plugin or app that runs on bare metal instead of a proof-of-work in the browser, because RandomX is designed such that it's slow when implemented in JS (https://github.com/tevador/RandomX/blob/master/doc/design.md)