logoalt Hacker News

mupuff1234today at 3:25 PM1 replyview on HN

I don't understand how come monorepos never just got "solved", and why git didn't expand in that direction.

I switched from a company with a monorepo to one without, and it just feels like going back to the stone age.


Replies

fcarraldotoday at 3:29 PM

I work at a monorepo company and any time someone gets to work on a project that necessitates working outside of the monorepo, it's a night-and-day improvement.

Tools, especially open source ones (linters, static analysis, scanning, LSPs, IDEs, etc) are not built for monorepos, and with AI Agents working in the monorepo results in an enormous increase in input tokens as the agents are constantly trying to grep this giant source tree.

I'm sure it's possible that we're doing the monorepo thing wrong, but I'm genuinely curious what the upside is that you're experiencing? Or are these drawbacks unique to our implementation?

show 1 reply