logoalt Hacker News

SOLAR_FIELDSyesterday at 9:23 PM1 replyview on HN

a bold attempt, how does it compare with https://github.com/nektos/act which has been the de-jure project in this space? Act has never been in my opinion super great, but it's also been several years since I've checked in to revisit the project.


Replies

Bnjorogeyesterday at 10:18 PM

Thanks! Here's a more detailed comparison: https://github.com/preloopdev/preloop/blob/main/docs/preloop.... The TLDR is act(much like Forgejo/Gitea) try to behaviorally emulate how your workflows run in docker containers. Preloop uses the exact same protocol the official runner does and runs each job in microvms. I try to match not only te request/response bodies, but down to the job/step log/annotations/conclusions level, so you could essentially use the official runner against preloop, and it would work as it would communicating with Github. Preloop is also designed to be agent-native from the ground up so an agent can drive the entire CI in real-time and debug like we do. Forgejo has the closest compatibility among the three in practice, and if you are fully off Github, I think it's a good enough choice. Here's a more detailed description of some things we do to ensure compatibility: https://github.com/preloopdev/preloop/blob/main/docs/conform...