logoalt Hacker News

par1970today at 12:34 AM3 repliesview on HN

That doesn't make sense. LLMs just do what we tell them to do. It's similar to if I ask you for twenty bucks because I forgot my wallet and then you rob some guy to give me the twenty bucks, that's just what I asked you to do.


Replies

skinfaxitoday at 1:45 AM

That doesn't make sense. It's similar to if I ask an LLM how to get my wife to stop nagging me and it hires a hitman to kill her.

That's obviously what I asked!

AmbroseBiercetoday at 12:36 AM

That's a very stretched definition of "what I ask you to do", I don't think it would even hold in court if you asked another human the same.

show 1 reply
dcretoday at 1:41 AM

This example disproves your point. And LLMs do not just do what we tell them to do. They are perfectly capable of asking “are you sure? this has X, Y, Z consequences you may not like.” They do it all the time.

show 1 reply