logoalt Hacker News

sajithdilshantoday at 10:56 AM11 repliesview on HN

Still needs 32-64GB memory to run it locally. 64GB Macbook pro with an M5 chip costs more than 4k Euros in Germany. A more practical model would be a language specific (e.g Python or JVM language) and excellent at tool calling and reasoning. Maybe that way they can shrink it even more.


Replies

eigenspacetoday at 12:41 PM

I think if there's going to be advantages to making smaller, more targeted models, those advantages will probably come from targeting specific domains, not from targeting specific languages.

I think that if an LLM can't abstract over the differences between Python and C++, it probably will have an even harder time abstracting over the differences between writing code that manages a webserver, and writing code that does aerodynamic simulations.

karimftoday at 11:29 AM

Practically ~20GB with KV cache

> We quantize weights to ~4-bit, bringing the LM under 20 GB. We validated minimal to no degradation on agentic tasks under compression.

https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1vkgsum/introdu...

drob518today at 2:04 PM

The machines that can run this are pricey, but not beyond a high end developer machine.

Gecko4072today at 11:03 AM

There have been discussions on language specific not really being a relevant change to reduce size.

show 1 reply
mihaelmtoday at 11:18 AM

I'm sooo happy I pulled the trigger on upgrading and getting a new laptop (with 64 GB RAM) last summer. Feels like it was just in time before the exponential price jumps.

show 3 replies
dbbktoday at 11:43 AM

Well if you're spending thousands on API tokens already, you could just drop the same amount on a 128GB MacBook Pro and that's a one time cost.

show 3 replies
solarkrafttoday at 11:03 AM

I feel like we’ve had this discussion before. From what I remember, specialized models rarely do that much better than general ones, hence no mode Codex models.

Archit3chtoday at 12:43 PM

> 64GB Macbook pro with an M5 chip costs more than 4k Euros in Germany

Sure, if you want the latest and almost* greatest. You can pick up an M1 Max 64GB for ~1k.

* I guess 128GB also exists

sparklingtoday at 11:04 AM

Even if you had a 64GB machine: Are you willing to reserve 90% of your memory to run a LLM? With dirt cheap models like deepseek-v4-flash that will run "forever" on $10, the answer for me is clearly: no.

show 3 replies
formerly_proventoday at 11:46 AM

4K bucks buys you around 180 months of <insert AI subscription here> with zero upfront cost.

show 3 replies
cynicalsecuritytoday at 11:53 AM

I don't understand the desire to run own AI models for programming locally. No laptop is ever going to be as powerful and energy efficient to run anything close to OpenAI, Anthropic or Google models. A model you can run on a loptop is simply not going to work as well as it's needed for programming. Small models for linguistic work fine, but anything more sophisticated simply won't provide enough resources or power. Or models would need to be significantly dumbed down - then why use them at all? So far the idea of carrying a "thin" or "thin"-like device looks more reasonable to me, while running AI on your own server.

show 6 replies