logoalt Hacker News

Roark66today at 1:57 PM2 repliesview on HN

This will not fly anywhere outside France Polish here and the very first question I have is "who would decide which cultural industry representatives would get the money"? And what right the decision makers have to decide that. How about they send few k EUR a month to my friend who is a struggling painter :-D

Somehow I doubt that will happen.

It reminds me of those taxes on CD-R disks to support "Art associations" that were proposed before.

Voices like this are useful to spark a debate on AI basically taking content owned by other people and selling it, but no one will agree to implement anything like what is proposed.


Replies

dwedgetoday at 2:03 PM

> This will not fly anywhere outside France Polish here

> It reminds me of those taxes on CD-R disks to support "Art associations" that were proposed before.

I find it funny when citizens of a country say things like this. Are you unaware that the Polish government brought in the same tax, 1-3%, on smartphones, laptops, desktop computers and SD cards from November this year? https://tvn24.pl/biznes/tech/nowa-oplata-od-smartfonow-table...

realusernametoday at 2:01 PM

> It reminds me of those taxes on CD-R disks to support "Art associations" that were proposed before.

They're not just proposed, they are implemented in a lot of countries and France actually has the highest CD tax in the EU (and probably in the world but I haven't checked)