logoalt Hacker News

gizajobtoday at 5:10 PM2 repliesview on HN

why is the Amen Brother breakbeat included in this software as if it's open source and GPL / MIT license? Just because something has been stolen a million times, that doesn't make it public domain, it's still under copyright and owned by its publisher, who I'm pretty certain has never given it away under a free license.


Replies

kyle-rbtoday at 7:42 PM

It's worth noting that the particular recording they include[0] is not the original performance, it's a CC0 (public domain) recreation of the sample.

So the recording itself has no copyright attached, but yes, there's still a question of the copyright on the composition.

[0] https://freesound.org/people/Dolfeus/sounds/43389/

noman-landtoday at 5:15 PM

I'd be really curious for this particular sample to go to court because unless The Winstons have been aggressively enforcing this copyright they may have already lost it to the public domain.

show 3 replies