logoalt Hacker News

siva7yesterday at 10:59 PM9 repliesview on HN

Have you thought for a single moment that this could save our profession? If people need a software development license to use AI for software development we wouldn't loose our jobs just like lawyers or doctors won't?


Replies

culitoday at 1:03 AM

Nobody wants to license programming. The skillsets are far too diverse and rapidly changing anyways. What programmers could use though is a union

mexicojaliscoyesterday at 11:04 PM

Furthermore everybody should need a license from the government or industry to cook morning breakfast on the stove. Fire hazards and all. Could do real harm if something went wrong.

show 1 reply
hboschyesterday at 11:05 PM

How much will a license cost? Can it be earned? If granted, granted by whom? Can I use it across models? Does it need to be reassessed regularly? How often?

If any of the above are more convenient than paying an engineer you aren’t any safer, the enterprise paying is just putting money in someone else’s pocket.

show 1 reply
bellowsgulchtoday at 1:00 AM

I don't want this, but I do get what you're saying. What I really want is software engineers in our industry to stop behaving like such idiot losers who are begging to be jobless and give everything away for free.

Doctors protect doctor's interests. Lawyers aren't idiots, they're professionals who run businesses with the express intent to make money.

Software engineers seem to be just bright enough to make money, and just stupid enough to say, no no, please I'd prefer to be homeless, please take my job and automate me, offshore me, and devalue my salary out of existence all at once.

show 2 replies
matheusmoreirayesterday at 11:31 PM

> just like lawyers or doctors won't

Pretty big assumption.

mpalmertoday at 12:45 AM

That would be doing the wrong thing for precisely the wrong reasons.

xyzzy123yesterday at 11:35 PM

I can't tell if your comment is satire or not, so, bravo :)

From my perspective what I always loved about "the profession" was a relative LACK of gatekeeping. I loved offensive security for the same reason, there was a long run where you really just needed to be able to hack, and if you could demonstrate that there was a job for you somewhere (for better or worse).

Keeping the industry in its current form frozen in amber would be as weird as, I don't know, keeping horses & carriages in business by regulating scarcity of motor vehicle licenses. Not a great analogy but hopefully you see what I mean.

prettyblockstoday at 1:38 AM

In what dystopian black mirror alternate reality can anyone possibly perceive this as saving the profession of programming? It sounds like hell.