logoalt Hacker News

inigyoutoday at 9:17 AM1 replyview on HN

Have you really backslid from "modern militaries don't rape and pillage" to "modern militaries rape and pillage, but it doesn't count because it's illegal"?


Replies

b112today at 12:16 PM

Backslid? What on Earth are you talking about?

If you read carefully, when pulled into deeper nuance, I'm consistently discussing what is legal behaviour for that military. Yes, there is a difference between "that military itself calls that act illegal" and "that military says it's OK to engage in that act". A massive difference.

And at no point did I lump all "modern militaries" together. In fact I specifically talked about democracies vs dictatorships in modern times, too.

So you're confusing "modern militaries rape and pillage" with "militaries' members rarely perform ilegal acts, and rape and pillage".

Or are you trying to claim it's standing, legal, normal operating procedure for the US military to rape? Are you?

Because with the framing you're using, that's what you're apparently trying to build here.