logoalt Hacker News

jvanderbottoday at 1:46 PM4 repliesview on HN

One issue that I have with many of these videos - what precisely is "this"? What issue is being addressed and what changes are proposed? It's entirely issue-adjacent slogans of "Amazon cheats, we will hurt them". And if I've learned anything from the most recent executive branch campaigns/elections, it's that vaguely defined "we'll get them" will get you elected but won't promise any meaningful changes other than power for the elected.


Replies

runakotoday at 1:58 PM

The bill[1], which is named in the video, is available on the public Internet.

1 - https://legistar.council.nyc.gov/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=7...

show 1 reply
rauljaratoday at 1:58 PM

I don’t think this video is about hurting anybody. It’s about making sure that large companies can be held liable if they hurt somebody. This is about protecting people.

ncallawaytoday at 2:05 PM

This video isn’t an attempt to get elected, since he’s six months into a term.

It’s an attempt to build political support for passing a specific piece of legislation. It’s not “vaguely defined”, it refers to a specific bill that he wants to pass that has legislative text available on the internet.

bryanlarsentoday at 2:15 PM

This is a concrete bill. It's the opponents that are going to need the catchy slogan to successfully defeat it.

Or bribes.