logoalt Hacker News

davexunityesterday at 9:34 PM3 repliesview on HN

> Not slop, though.

What would you call 2k commits in 2 months by a single committer if not slop?


Replies

broken-kebabyesterday at 10:27 PM

'Slop' is a word about quality, like in 'AI slop' - a low quality code generated with LLM. Did OP managed to achieve reasonable quality notwithstanding the speed? I don't know yet, but unless you can point to something sloppy in the repo, calling it slop may not be warranted.

yogthosyesterday at 9:50 PM

If you have any actual constructive criticism of the code, then I'd love to hear them.

show 1 reply
rahenyesterday at 9:43 PM

It definitely is vibe-coded, but yogthos is a competent programmer who has been working on public Clojure projects and repos since 2009, and has maintained a large Clojure framework since well before LLMs were a thing.

I don't think "2k commits in 2 months" is enough to dismiss as slop when it's being developed by a competent Clojure dev.

show 1 reply