logoalt Hacker News

apitoday at 2:35 PM3 repliesview on HN

That is true of all tools. AI is a tool. A tool provides leverage. It does not make a bad craftsperson good.


Replies

dgellowtoday at 2:45 PM

I hate that framing because it glosses over what makes AI distinct from other technology. Pretty much anything can be used as a tool, that’s not an interesting aspect of AI. However standard tools do not take decisions on behalf of the user, they do not apply judgement. They come with assumptions and constraints that make some decisions more likely to be made. But the whole thing about LLMs is that they apply judgement and take decisions. When you use an LLM you delegate both aspects to it with very little overview or control.

I don’t think it’s “just a tool”, it’s something that directly compete with the role of humans in a system, by design

show 1 reply
subygantoday at 2:59 PM

Ai is a tool in the same way an employee is a tool. very unlike a hammer.

mikert89today at 2:36 PM

right but we have never seen a tool like this

show 1 reply