logoalt Hacker News

edenttoday at 6:27 PM4 repliesview on HN

The UK has no constitutional method to remove a PM.

The USA does have a constitutional method to remove a President.

Nevertheless, in living memory all Presidents have survived their impeachments. Whereas (with the exceptions of Major, Brown, and Sunak) all UK Primes Minister have been removed while in office.

It makes an interesting study in the effectiveness of a written and inflexible constitution.


Replies

rsynnotttoday at 10:28 PM

> The UK has no constitutional method to remove a PM.

It absolutely does. Now, it's rare that it is used, because normally the party will dump the leader first (or simply implicitly threaten to). But it exists.

graemeptoday at 6:42 PM

A PM can be removed by a vote of no confidence.

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/votes-of-no-confidence/

bmsleight_today at 6:37 PM

>The UK has no constitutional method to remove a PM. I not sure this is correct, a vote of confidence in Parliament. Will bring down the government. Hence the PM.

show 1 reply
snowpidtoday at 6:57 PM

Sorry but today anyone can shit on the USA. Compare the UK to working democracies. Italy has clearly a written constitution and has seen way more Prime Ministers than the UK.