alt Hacker NewsIs there anything he's said in particular that, given the benefit of hindsight, you feel has turned out to be misleading in retrospect?
Speaking for myself only, but if I were going to post a comment like yours on a public forum insinuating doubts about a specific person and vaguely implying their analysis is not trustworthy, I'd come armed with at least once example.
If we were talking about random niche people or some kind of inside drop on information, sure. But this is a generic argument lodged against one of the big prolific content creators, which means that the burden of evidence really falls on anyone who has the energy and will to spend. The information is well exposed and catalogued.
For people with 1M+ followers, anything that could be said has already likely been said.