logoalt Hacker News

1970-01-01today at 4:38 PM2 repliesview on HN

Spin gets you centripetal force. You know where inside and outside are globally because the forces will be opposite depending on which "side" you're standing, which directly contradicts their statement "..globally you cannot label one side as up and one side as down. If you try to label one side as up, and then you move continuously around the Möbius strip, you'll end up labelling that same side as down!"


Replies

karmakurtisaanitoday at 5:13 PM

I get what you're saying, but with the spin you need to introduce the notion of movement, mass and force. It adds complexity you might not be able to afford, especially since typically you want to investigate a whole bunch of shapes, not just one strip.

Also, since everything on your model is continuous, there must be a point on the strip where the centrifugal force is 0. Is that point inside or outside?

show 2 replies
sreantoday at 4:59 PM

Got you.