logoalt Hacker News

keedayesterday at 7:35 PM0 repliesview on HN

While TFA itself makes sense I disagree with the title and the conclusion. I would not consider referencing working memory during thinking as “remembering” but as a part of thinking itself. Working memory is the RAM to the much larger but higher latency indexed database that is our long-term memory. As such I would say AI is out-thinking us, even if in a brute force sort of way.

I think where you could say it is out-remembering us is when it can contemplate the vast universe of patterns, gleaned from essentially all human disciplines, encoded in its weights, that may let it draw connections that a human could not, unless they just happen to be familiar with multiple disciplines.

Which is why I think the analogy with Von Neumann / Einstein is also a bit off. From TFA it seems Von Neumann was more akin to what AI does, than Einstein. I don’t get the impression that it was Einstein’s memory but his ability to look at things from a radically different perspective. So far I don’t know that we can categorically say that LLMs can or cannot do that.