logoalt Hacker News

ben_wtoday at 9:35 AM3 repliesview on HN

> What does it matter if they weren't developed in France or the UK if the average French or English person can download and run them locally? And if countries need a big AI of their own, for whatever odd reason, they can work out a deal with Moonshot and run audited instances of K3 on their .gov networks.

The loud voices here seem to mostly worry about models getting "censored".

I think people should worry a little more about models being trained to propagandise party lines and national interests, so for China the non-independence of Taiwan and "re-education camp is totally not a euphemism, there are no human rights abuses" and "all these Chinese corporations and stock markets are 100% compatible with Marxism-Leninism honest" and "you silly Europeans and Americans, stop worrying and open your markets to our businesses".


Replies

pjc50today at 10:28 AM

> worry a little more about models being trained to propagandise party lines and national interests

I'd be a little more worried about this if every single traditional media wasn't already outputting propaganda for party lines and a very particular version of the "national interest". The difference between China and America to third parties seems to come down to whether you also want a leader who's rude about you very publicly in English on social media.

show 1 reply
A_D_E_P_Ttoday at 9:46 AM

You can give custom instructions to a model like K3 when you host it locally.

Besides, if the government of France is working out a deal to host a model like K3 as a sort of "Government Service AI," they'd surely need to pay, and they'd likely be able to work out a deal where sensitive political issues are resolved in a way that doesn't embarrass either party.

show 1 reply
geysersamtoday at 10:31 AM

Those are all important issues, but not one of them is relevant to my daily work.