logoalt Hacker News

Incipienttoday at 3:09 PM4 repliesview on HN

I actually really enjoyed the game on day 1!

Unfortunately, even with all the updates - they never fixed my main gripe - each planet is just lifeless, and it's basically the same few square kilometres copy and pasted over the whole planet (I'm about 120h played).

I wished they somehow made it more exciting to explore.


Replies

seanalltogethertoday at 3:46 PM

And apparently this is one of the main criticisms of Starfield. The Bethesda designers either never played No Mans Sky to understand the problem, or they simply believed a large enough budget could mask these problems.

maxlintoday at 3:35 PM

Same. Played thru the original version. The overall vibe of the game was great and incredibly polished for a game half done, but yeah it was stretched very thin and started to lose feeling after a while.

That said,idk if I would like the fame at all now. Base building seems antithetical to the original nomad-like setting. And there's only loss to have adding identity to the protagonist after having played it as "yourself"

enraged_cameltoday at 3:11 PM

I think that's the limit of procedural generation. What you're asking for probably requires gen-AI or similar.

show 3 replies
squigztoday at 3:11 PM

Have you played somewhat recently? They've had a few expeditions that addressed variety in planets.