logoalt Hacker News

ben_wyesterday at 7:51 PM4 repliesview on HN

> Eating meat fills my belly.

So do many other things which use less water.

The estimates I've seen place the water consumption of water at such a low level that a whole month subscription consumes roughly as much water as 1-120 grams* of beef.

> Setting my AC to 68 keeps me cool.

What, is 70 not good enough?

Air con, and basically all things connected to the power grid, also "costs [your] community money, damages the environment directly and indirectly, and further enriches a few already rich people."

* yes, one to one hundred and twenty, there's that much uncertainty in the estimates for the AI.


Replies

magicalistyesterday at 8:18 PM

When Amazon gets to run an offgrid power plant for a new data centre that's permitted to release more co2 than any other single power plant in the US[1], you'll pardon me for wondering what the rush is and why it becomes literally everyone else's problem as a result.

Build the data centre, sure, but if it takes you five years to build out the grid and sufficient generating capacity in a non stupid way in order to do that, sorry, but that's by far my preferred route to get there.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/08/climate/amazon-data-cente...

show 1 reply
DeluluDonyesterday at 8:06 PM

>Air con, and basically all things connected to the power grid, also "costs [your] community money,

In what country do you not have an electric bill?

show 1 reply
watwutyesterday at 11:36 PM

Water issue is highly local. Eating meat from where it grew has zero impact on whether this or that datacenter waste water where it is expensive or lacking.

These bad faith "but you exist and do unrelated things" fallacies are a.) bad faith b.) make people have ai people more.

Bringing uo AC while you defend datacenters making global warming worst is just a cherry on top.of it. Just underlines anti-human fck you all ideology of it all.

jplusequaltyesterday at 8:21 PM

Does that water usage take into account all the water that went into training the models, including the electricity it took run the data centers the GPUs are housed in?

show 1 reply