logoalt Hacker News

alightsoultoday at 8:15 PM4 repliesview on HN

The only way to have agi or any ai is to throw away all ethics then. So why are ai companies shredding books instead of using Anna's archive? Depending on your stance, one is more ethical than the other, but not both. And not neither of them.


Replies

selcukatoday at 10:26 PM

> why are ai companies shredding books instead of using Anna's archive?

I'm pretty sure they've already consumed everything on Anna's archive, Pirate Bay etc and they are now buying books to fill the gaps.

root_axistoday at 8:57 PM

I'm sure they're using whatever they can get their hands on, including Anna's archive. The business process of buying books to scan offers the opportunity to ingest media that hasn't yet been digitized, but also provides plausible legal deniability against copyright holders bringing litigation.

noosphrtoday at 8:32 PM

Anna's archive is missing books and papers.

andrewflnrtoday at 8:32 PM

Abandoning ethics doesn't mean you actively seek out unethical acts, it just means you only care about pragmatics. Limiting how overtly you break the law, copyright law in this case, is often pragmatic regardless of ethics.