logoalt Hacker News

DaiPlusPlusyesterday at 11:36 PM6 repliesview on HN

I have no exposure to connectomes - or really anything quite like this (as opposed to good ol’ fashioned perceptrons) - so forgive my following uninformed question:

Can someone explain if this software is ethical?


Replies

jephsyesterday at 11:49 PM

If your circle of empathy includes fruit flies, fuck no, we murdered so many of those guys to figure out how their tiny brains work.

If you do not think of fruit flies as moral patients, sure, yeah, who cares, they're like just fruit flies you know?

lp4v4ntoday at 1:27 AM

How could this be anti-ethical? You're just running a very complex algorithm in your machine.

show 1 reply
janalsncmyesterday at 11:46 PM

> Can someone explain if this software is ethical?

Probably not. People have been coming up with ethical frameworks for thousands of years and we have yet to come to a consensus.

So it’s very unlikely that someone can say conclusively whether this is ethical or not, because that would require us to either 1) prove a single ethical framework is correct and then apply that framework to this software or 2) prove that under all possible ethical frameworks this software is either ethical or not ethical.

show 2 replies
hellohello2today at 1:50 AM

Yes I can, no problem. First figure out how consciousness works and tell me, then I'll be able to explain if the software is ethical or not. Its simple really.

ramraj07yesterday at 11:38 PM

Why do you think it wont be?

show 1 reply