logoalt Hacker News

MomsAVoxelltoday at 11:15 AM2 repliesview on HN

Do you not understand the immense amount of energy and resources required to manufacture a single consumable cartridge?

The point is to avoid that entirely and harvest gravity.

Re-wilding teams already climb far and wide, and this would extend their reach without increasing their dependencies.

Ammo is a dependency.


Replies

anon_cow1111today at 11:47 AM

Do you not understand your argument is exploring a made-up scenario where we're no longer an industrialized civilization where these things are manufactured cheaply by the billions?

And if you INSIST on making everything completely low-tech and renewable, build a potato gun and use high-proof alcohol as fuel. It'll weigh less and last longer than whatever rube-Goldberg trebuchet design you have.

show 1 reply
p1mrxtoday at 12:00 PM

Gravity is not "harvested", it just stores the energy briefly. Someone or something has to lift the weight for every shot, which requires energy.

It's not obvious whether a trebuchet is better than compressed air, like a BB gun.

show 1 reply