logoalt Hacker News

shevy-javayesterday at 9:55 PM2 repliesview on HN

Why would it be a "stretch"?

The basic requirement is whether the source code is available - and made available. Are you certain that Google's solution here is ensuring that the source code is easily made available? So many other projects just provide a wget-able link. Why does Google want to make it harder to obtain the source code than those other projects?

> Android has always been more source-open than “open source”.

And what exactly does that mean? I don't know what your words mean here. More source open than open source? Is that a tautology?

> Everything else is essentially all the work of Google and (to some extent) Samsung.

Is it GPLv2? If so then I fail to see why anyone should get higher rights. Everyone gets the same for GPLv2. That's the whole point. I don't understand your statements here.


Replies

demibabsyesterday at 11:57 PM

> The basic requirement is whether the source code is available - and made available. Are you certain that Google's solution here is ensuring that the source code is easily made available?

The word “easily” sure did sneak into this sentence

knollimaryesterday at 10:15 PM

"And what exactly does that mean? I don't know what your words mean here. More source open than open source? Is that a tautology?"

I'm sure this means the source happens to be open rather than following the spirit of open source.