logoalt Hacker News

math-mantoday at 2:53 AM3 repliesview on HN

It's because both radians and degrees are are a ratio of a length to another length and are thus dimensionless. No matter how you measure it, all angles are without a unit.

It's most obvious with radians but it's also the case with degrees.

Using radians, you are guaranteed to not introduce unusual extra terms to rescale angles, if you use any other scale of angle you will have to keep track of extra terms.

That may be useful in whatever you're doing. I work in degrees quite often and I'm careful to keep track of the 2pi/360 terms that crop up all over the place. With grade measure you have to keep track of 2pi/400 terms and with turns you have to keep track of 2pi/1 terms that will repeatedly show up.

Again, depending on what you're doing, this may or may not make sense to do.

In general, mathematics works out easier when the scaling term is 2pi/2pi because then you have a lovely 1 scale factor you don't have to keep track of.


Replies

sreantoday at 7:02 AM

It is dimensionless by fiat and convention. It clearly has units such as degrees, grad and radians. Just like other quantities that have units, a specific measurement is expressed as a pure numerical multiple of an unit which may be radians, degrees etc.

This is a known wrinkle in dimensional analysis and people have considered making angles a fundamental quantity such as mass, length and time but have not done so because of the disruption it would cause.

More details here

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radian#Dimensional_analysis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angle#Dimensional_analysis

show 1 reply
erutoday at 3:16 AM

Agreed. Though sometimes it's useful to keep track of 'fake' units like for angles, to make something like dimensional analysis work for you.

But that's more for analysis of your code / formulas than when you actually go and compute things.

daharttoday at 5:59 AM

> all angles are without a unit.

Dimensionless, sure, but what do you mean here? Radians and degrees are units, are they not?

show 1 reply