logoalt Hacker News

sajithdilshantoday at 8:13 PM9 repliesview on HN

The comments just shows how entitled people have become. Most people use GitHub and features for free and have the audacity to complain.

The outage is due to massive load increase. In 4 months the number of commits doubled to 2.9 Billions. Anyone worked with high load systems knows that’s it’s not a normal growth and how difficult even to keep on horizontally scaling in a short time period such a complex system.

GitHub should charge at least maybe 5$ monthly fee and most of the entitled freeloaders would leave the platform and it would free up resources


Replies

thesdevtoday at 9:01 PM

> the entitled freeloaders

Now remind me again, who trained a coding-assistant without consent on those "freeloaders" code and sold it for profit?

Vegenoidtoday at 9:53 PM

Using a corporation's free offerings isn't freeloading. Microsoft wants people to put their code on GitHub. They want GitHub to be the place where source code is hosted, it is incredibly valuable. Saying "GitHub is sucking and I might leave" is information that Microsoft wants to know if they want to preserve GitHub's dominance.

Of course some people take it too far. Of course there are reasons that the outages are occurring. But Microsoft wants GitHub to be a core, reliable pillar of the software world. Nobody's making them do that, they do it because it's good for them.

dataplumb3rtoday at 10:11 PM

True but paid users are also impacted.

We're still staying on Github at work, but have had backup self hosted git repos as a break glass option when Github is completely broken and leveraged this several times now.

jiehongtoday at 9:39 PM

It seems that paid users are equally impacted as free users.

It sounds a little bit unfair to me.

lysacetoday at 9:03 PM

"Most people use GitHub and features for free"

Do you have a source for that factoid? (I suspect the vast majority of Github resource usage is paid. And we are upset.)

show 1 reply
ssl-3today at 9:03 PM

Entitlement? Please. It's not like Github is a charity that operates on kindness and goodwill.

It's a service that is owned and operated by Microsoft Corporation, and we're the product of it.

dupedtoday at 9:32 PM

I mean, a lot of us have paid GitHub a lot of money for CI on private repos. And when GitHub themselves encourages the insane behavior of vibe coders and agents instead of just charging or rate limiting access of bots, it's hard to give them sympathy.

XorNottoday at 9:54 PM

LOL. If it dies, it dies.

People take the weirdest rhetorical hostages.

jollyllamatoday at 9:15 PM

Meh, just needs better QoS. Let the free tier shoulder the outages.