logoalt Hacker News

giantg2today at 10:07 PM2 repliesview on HN

"Maybe the real issue is selective outrage about legal injustice."

The real issue is selective enforcement of the law. If it applied equally to everyone, then more people would be outraged as it affected them.


Replies

genghisjahntoday at 10:49 PM

For the in-crowd the law protects but does not bind. For the out-crowd, the law binds but does not protect.

Can’t remember where I read that but it has stuck with me.

show 2 replies
jmward01today at 10:30 PM

Perfectly equal enforcement really isn't possible, but it should be the policy to enforce in proportion to active harm. The bigger the ongoing active harm, the quicker to react we should be. Some individual torrents a single movie? NBD. No matter the side of the argument you are on this should be ignored. A company intentionally throws content strikes causing legitimate harm to large numbers of content creators? That should addressed.

Reality should always have a place in the law.

show 3 replies