alt Hacker NewsHi Joseph,
A story for a story. I had my CRDT implementation in libdog, which does per-token CRDT weave/diff/merge over a DAG of git blobs. It was written by Claude 4.8 I believe, in several iterations. It was, as you may guess, a piece of neuro-slop that passed the tests by some miracle. Once I had some time to look into it, I used a trick: I supplied it with my article on Chronofolds and some helpful kicks in the butt. It implemented everything correctly on its k-th attempt, k<5. Then I used it with full intensity for three months without thinking twice. Now I have started mass-using it to resolve permalinks in the code. Like, tens of files to chronofold-ize per one commit. It is now showing up in the profile, so I may look into it once more.
Conclusion: it sort of expands its context and prompt by association. It has no sense of direction of its own maybe. Once you know what you are doing, you can ride it fine. If not, it makes a misstep so later things go haywire, and you are left guessing why. (And how can you guess if you have not had the experience. We all grew with Commodores and suchlike. I recall Spectrums, Robotrons, and Poisks. My friend sits on exam committees, says the youth arrives flatlined after 3 years of GPT. His words. Whatever.)
> It has no sense of direction of its own maybe. Once you know what you are doing, you can ride it fine. If not, it makes a misstep so later things go haywire, and you are left guessing why.
This is a perfect description. Last week I asked claude opus to get AAC audio working in davinci resolve on linux. It managed to add aac in mov and mp4 containers very quickly. But mkv was another matter. For mkv files, resolve doesn't use ffmpeg. Instead, it has its own parser. Claude got totally lost down a weird rabbit hole trying to add aac support to resolve's mkv code. It was really struggling. Claude even knew it was lost - it kept telling me we should cut our losses and I should just release aac support without mkv.
Eventually I gave it the executable for davinci resolve on mac, which has aac support. Claude found the corresponding part of the code for the mac version and used it as a reference. Turns out, claude had made some much earlier mistake. Just like you said, it was going down a wrong path. Then it couldn't stop itself, and it kept making it worse.
Using the mac version of the binary as a reference, claude figured out how to get everything working very quickly. But - I'm left wondering. Maybe my real mistake was using Opus and not Fable. I wonder if fable would have been smart enough to figure out the mistake and course-correct.