logoalt Hacker News

jeffrallentoday at 12:52 PM0 repliesview on HN

Fine article, though it ended on a low note with the comment about cryptography engineers gatekeeping the technology.

I have worked on high stakes crypto code. Getting it right requires a level of knowledge, care and engineering conservativism that is very hard to come by. I was teaching students. I wasn't gatekeeping. But a vanishingly small percentage of them were able to make secure software, or analyze existing code to know if it was secure.

In as much as AI coding makes testing or code verification cheaper, sure let's use it. But cryptography engineering is hard for reasons that are not "write moar code" and so AI coding should not be used on production crypto work.