logoalt Hacker News

UI_at_80x24today at 1:10 PM4 repliesview on HN

Given the context, your domain name is 'chefs kiss', perfect.

I am completely curious what your legal defense would be though.

"Come do things with AI that are probably illegal!"

What?! We had no idea people would do things that are illegal!


Replies

mdp2021today at 2:28 PM

> defense

Improper use is that of the user, not inherent to the tool.

Scolio: guns. Respondeo: guns are much more specialized (one-use) than knives. Proper use of sharp knives when what was shipped was a butter knife is understandable.

(The simile is not fully overlapping but should give the idea. The instrument must be flexible; if it is misused it is then a responsibility of the abuser.)

wongarsutoday at 1:57 PM

There is very little information that is illegal by itself. At least in the Western World, and especially in the US. The question is how far you get into the territory of aiding and abetting a crime

But the reasonable defense is that the intended use cases are legal. The home page list a couple, and the 'writing fiction'/'helping authors' case alone covers almost everything. An author asking you how to best conduct a terrorist attack or how Meth is made are perfectly normal. Maybe even tame, compared to what some authors tend to research

TofuLovertoday at 1:28 PM

I guess we'll burn that bridge when we get to it!

show 1 reply
weberertoday at 2:20 PM

What can a LLM generate that's illegal in the USA? Specifically a text-only LLM?

show 2 replies