logoalt Hacker News

unsnap_bicepsyesterday at 11:18 PM1 replyview on HN

Climate change is a lot of different things. For the statement that the count matters and a "tree is a tree",

Carbon sequestration? A giant redwood stores more carbon than a fir.

Healthy ecosystems? Different trees fit into different roles in a healthy forest.

The loss of biodiversity? Once a forest dies, a new forest somewhere else doesn't bring back the lost biodiversity.

In theory, Carbon sequestration is the closest to "a tree is a tree", you can plant large amounts of fast growing trees can capture more carbon over time, but that's specifying the later tree, which then matters.


Replies

card_zeroyesterday at 11:24 PM

Why did you mention ecosystems and biodiversity? Is the idea that those store more carbon, too, or was it just gratuitous?

Edit after downvote: but why though? It looks like conflation of climate change with the entirety of environmentalism. That is a misleading thing to do.

show 1 reply