logoalt Hacker News

r3trohack3rtoday at 3:19 PM5 repliesview on HN

America does it with 50 states


Replies

akietoday at 4:23 PM

I know that this is a popular point-of-view in the US, but your states and legislative processes are all very homogeneous in comparison. You guys mostly speak the same language, you have the same cultural touch points, you have a shared history, shared media, and mostly centralized power.

Your country looks more like Germany (and if you know your history, that's no coincidence) than it looks like the EU.

show 1 reply
bryanlarsentoday at 3:23 PM

That analogy would hold only if inter-state commerce was the responsibility of the states rather than the federal government.

aleph_minus_onetoday at 6:45 PM

> America does it with 50 states

And Germany has 16 federal states.

denotoday at 3:32 PM

And EU does it with VAT-OSS scheme which was also separate in each country before. There's just no will to do this with EPR because there's too much money and lobbying power in the recycling cartel.

show 1 reply
voakbasdatoday at 3:45 PM

In theory, true. In practice, state independence has been dead for the better part of a century.

The 10th amendment has been eviscerated by the courts. By a strict reading of its relatively simple language, most of what the federal government does is unconstitutional.

Today, USA is unabbreviated as the “United States of America”, but the country was founded as the “United States for Anerica”.

As such, I am strongly in favor of returning to our former glory by stripping the federal government of most of its power and transferring it to the states.

I am also wise enough to know that will never happen without a long and bloody revolution, and I am okay with that given the lived reality that has defined my life.

We live in tyranny. You may not feel the rolling boil of the water that surrounds you, my fellow Americans, but make no mistake: your goose is cooked.

show 4 replies